Muhle R89 vs Edwin Jagger DE89: Same Razor, Different Brand
The Muhle R89 and Edwin Jagger DE89 are widely reported by shavers to feel close to identical, and some community posts claim they share a head, but neither Mühle nor Edwin Jagger states that.
What actually separates the two is handle material, weight balance, and price, not blade angle or aggressiveness.
Shavory earns a commission on qualifying purchases through the Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Picks are chosen on performance and value, not on commission.
Shavory earns a commission on qualifying purchases through the Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Picks are chosen on performance and value, not on commission.
Where the Two Razors Are Basically Twins
Both use a closed comb head with a mild, forgiving blade gap. If you have already read our Edwin Jagger DE89 review, you already know how the R89 performs, because shavers report the two heads perform almost identically.
Beginners get the same easy learning curve on both. Neither razor punishes a slightly wrong angle, which is why both show up on almost every best safety razor for beginners list.
| Razor | Head | Finish | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mühle R89 | Closed comb, mild | Chrome-plated | Beginners who prefer a slimmer handle |
| Edwin Jagger DE89 | Closed comb, mild | Chrome-plated | Beginners who want the most-recommended default |
Where the Handles Actually Differ
The Muhle R89 handle has a slightly heavier, more substantial feel with a textured barrel grip. The Edwin Jagger DE89 leans lighter with a smoother, more tapered handle.
If your hands sweat during a shave, the Muhle grip pattern gives you more traction. If you prefer a lighter razor that lets the blade do the work, Edwin Jagger edges it out.
Closed comb headChrome finishStandard double edge blade
Handle metalWeightGripList price
Mühle R89 vs Edwin Jagger DE89 vs Merkur 34C: official specs and list prices
| Razor | Weight | Length | Handle material | Head | Maker list price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mühle R89 | 70 g (EU page), 70.3 g (US page) | 94 mm (EU page), 92 mm (US page) | Chrome-plated metal; brass is not stated | Closed comb, chrome-plated | $48.00 (Mühle US store); 37,00 EUR (Mühle EU shop) |
| Edwin Jagger DE89 | 68 g (2.4 oz) | 93 mm overall, 83 mm handle | Solid brass, triple-plated chrome | Two-piece die-cast, chrome-plated closed comb | $44.18 RRP (US storefront) |
| Merkur 34C | 78 g | 81 x 43 x 25 mm product size | Brass handle, bright chrome plating | Zinc die-cast head with cap and comb, closed comb | 52,00 EUR incl. 19% German VAT |
List prices read on each maker’s own site, checked October 2026: Mühle US, Mühle EU, Edwin Jagger and Merkur. Merkur sells in euros only. Length figures come from each maker’s own page and may not be measured the same way. Amazon prices change daily; the buttons show today’s price.
Price and Where to Spend the Difference
Edwin Jagger models are usually priced slightly lower than comparable Muhle handles at street price. Neither price gap reflects a real difference in shave quality.
Once you have chosen your razor, spend the saved money on technique. Learning how to use a safety razor properly will affect your results more than which of these two handles you pick.
What do these razors cost over the years you keep them?
Formula: shaves a year = shaves per week x 52. Blades a year = shaves a year / shaves per blade. Blade cost a year = blades a year x (pack price / blades in pack). Total = razor price + blade cost a year x years. Cost per shave = total / (shaves a year x years). The Merkur price is euros x the rate above.
Check price on AmazonMühle R89
Check price on AmazonEdwin Jagger DE89
Which One Should You Actually Buy
Buy whichever handle feels better in your hand at the price you are comfortable paying. The heads perform almost alike, so the handle is what you are really choosing.
